The Complete Guide to Trading Card Grading Companies

September 20, 2025

The Complete Guide to Trading Card Grading Companies:

Which One Should You Choose?

Whether you're a seasoned collector or just starting your journey into trading cards, understanding card grading is essential for protecting and maximizing the value of your collection. At Fan-Tastic Cards & Comics, we help collectors navigate the world of graded cards every day, and one of the most common questions we hear is: "Which grading company should I use?"

What is Card Grading?

Card grading is the process of having your trading cards professionally authenticated and evaluated by third-party companies. These companies assess the condition of your cards using standardized criteria and encapsulate them in protective cases with assigned grades. This process provides several benefits:

Authentication: Verification that your card is genuine
Condition Assessment: Professional evaluation of wear, centering, corners, and edges
Protection: Secure encapsulation that preserves the card's condition
Market Value: Graded cards typically command higher prices than raw cards

The Major Grading Companies

PSA (Professional Sports Authenticator)

Founded: 1991
Grading Scale: 1-10 (with half-point grades for certain vintage cards)
Specialty: Sports cards, Pokémon, and other trading cards

PSA is widely considered the gold standard in card grading, especially for sports cards and Pokémon. Their population reports are comprehensive, and PSA 10 cards typically command the highest premiums in the market.

Pros:

Highest market recognition and resale value
Excellent population tracking
Strong authentication processes
Clear, durable cases

Cons:

Longest turnaround times (often 6+ months for standard service)
Most expensive grading fees
Strict grading standards can result in lower grades

Best For: High-value vintage cards, modern rookies, and Pokémon cards where maximum resale value is the priority.

BGS (Beckett Grading Services)

Founded: 1999
Grading Scale: 1-10 (with half-point increments)
Specialty: Modern sports cards and gaming cards

BGS offers subgrades for centering, corners, edges, and surface, providing detailed feedback on each aspect of the card's condition. They offer both "Pristine 10" grades (perfect 10 with subgrades of 9.5-10) and the coveted "Black Label" 10 (perfect scores in all four subgrade categories), which is considered the holy grail of modern card grading.

Pros:

Detailed subgrade system
Excellent for modern cards
Black Label 10s command premium prices
Generally faster than PSA
Pristine 10s offer middle ground between regular 10s and Black Labels

Cons:

Less market recognition than PSA for vintage cards
More expensive than budget options
Subgrades can be inconsistent

Best For: Modern sports cards, especially when you want detailed condition feedback or are targeting a Pristine or Black Label grade.

SGC (Sportscard Guaranty Corporation)

Founded: 1998
Grading Scale: 1-10 (whole numbers only)
Specialty: Vintage sports cards

SGC has built a strong reputation, particularly for vintage cards. They're known for consistent grading and have gained significant market share in recent years.

Pros:

Consistent, reliable grading
Faster turnaround times than PSA
Competitive pricing
Growing market acceptance
Excellent vintage card expertise

Cons:

Less market premium than PSA for most cards
Limited population data compared to PSA
Newer company with less historical data

Best For: Vintage sports cards, collectors seeking consistent grading, and those wanting faster service than PSA.

CGC (Certified Guaranty Company)

Founded: 2020 (for trading cards)
Grading Scale: 1-10 (with half-point grades)
Specialty: Pokémon, gaming cards, and modern sports cards

CGC entered the trading card market in 2020, bringing decades of experience from comic book grading. They've quickly gained traction, especially in the Pokémon community.

Pros:

Fast turnaround times
Competitive pricing
Experience from comic grading
Growing acceptance in Pokémon market
Good customer service

Cons:

Newest company with limited market history
Lower resale premiums compared to established companies
Still building population databases

Best For: Pokémon cards, modern gaming cards, and collectors seeking fast, affordable grading.

HGA (Hybrid Grading Approach)

Founded: 2021
Grading Scale: 1-10 (with half-point grades)
Specialty: Modern cards with custom label options

HGA offered unique custom labels and positioned itself as a more collector-friendly option with transparent grading processes. However, the company announced restructuring in 2024, creating uncertainty about their current operations and long-term viability.

Pros:

Custom label options (when operational)
Transparent grading videos
Competitive pricing
Fast turnaround times

Cons:

Company restructuring creates uncertainty
Limited market acceptance
Questionable long-term viability
Lower resale values

Best For: Currently not recommended due to operational uncertainty. Consider other options for new submissions.

Factors to Consider When Choosing a Grading Company

1. Card Type and Era

Vintage Sports Cards (pre-1980): PSA or SGC
Modern Sports Cards: BGS or PSA
Pokémon Cards: PSA or CGC
Gaming Cards: CGC or BGS

2. Your Goals

Maximum Resale Value: PSA
Detailed Condition Analysis: BGS
Fast Service: SGC or CGC
Budget-Friendly: CGC or SGC

3. Turnaround Time

Fastest: CGC (weeks to 1-2 months)
Moderate: SGC, BGS (2-4 months)
Slowest: PSA (4-8+ months for standard service)

4. Cost Considerations

Grading fees vary by company and service level:

Budget Options: CGC, SGC ($15-25 per card)
Mid-Range: BGS ($20-40 per card)
Premium: PSA ($25-50+ per card)

Note: Prices vary by service level and card value

Tips for Successful Grading

Pre-screen Your Cards: Only grade cards that appear to be in excellent condition
Research Population Reports: Check if your card is already heavily graded.
Review Card Markets: Compare the market rate between various platforms, taking into account raw vs graded price.
Consider Market Demand: Some cards perform better with certain grading companies
Factor in Total Costs: Include grading fees, shipping, and insurance
Be Patient: Quality grading takes time

Our Recommendation at Fan-Tastic

For most collectors, we typically recommend:

PSA for high-value vintage cards and Pokémon where maximum resale value is important
SGC for vintage sports cards when you want reliable grading with faster service
BGS for modern sports cards, especially when targeting Pristine or Black Label grades
CGC for Pokémon and gaming cards when speed and value are priorities

Getting Started with Grading

If you're new to grading, consider starting with a few lower-value cards to understand the process. Many collectors begin with CGC or SGC for their faster turnaround times and competitive pricing.

At Fan-Tastic Cards & Comics, we're always happy to help you evaluate whether your cards are good candidates for grading. While we don't grade cards in-house, our experienced team can provide visual assessments and help you understand what to expect from the grading process.

Ready to start grading your collection? Stop by Fan-Tastic Cards & Comics in Asheville, NC, or contact us for personalized advice on your specific cards. We're here to help you make the best decisions for your collection!

Visit us at fan-tasticshop.com or call (828) 505-0933 for more information.

Back to blog